A Lie That’s Making Our Neighborhoods Less Safe

Let’s get something straight: the City of LA has not defunded the LAPD. Not even close.

Political candidates, the police union, talk radio, and social media are all shouting about defunding and its consequences. There’s a false narrative that says “progressives defunded police, crime is up, and we need more cops (and fewer progressives) to keep us safe.”

But it is a liea lie that is making us and our neighborhoods less safe. It is an active, coordinated effort to stop efforts to reimagine public safety, build safe communities, and dismantle systemic racism.

They want you to think that police are the answer to every problem, that you can’t be safe unless we have more and more cops. They don’t want us investing more wisely in things that actually prevent crime: Jobs. Housing. Healthcare. Education. Opportunity.

This year’s LAPD budget is $1.76 billion, a 3% *increase* from last year. LAPD’s budget has increased every year for the past decade, except in 2020–21, when there was a 2% cut that was essentially negated by higher overtime spending. In fact, the police budget is close to 30% of the entire city budget (and 50% of our unrestricted funds). Yet certain people repeatedly insist LAPD has been gutted, and violent crime is spiking as a result. One LA police union director even went on TV to warn people to stay away from LA.

But more police spending doesn’t mean reduced crime. Crime has gone up in years when LAPD got an increase, and has gone down in years it got a cut. And worth noting: violent crime is up nationwide — including in cities that increased police funding even more than LA.

It’s not that we are paying LAPD too little to fight crime; it’s that we are investing too little in preventing crime. LA has barely begun to reimagine public safety, with little more than small pilot programs and stalled legislative efforts to show for it.

To be safe, LA needs big investments in jobs, education, mental health & drug treatment, housing, youth programs, violence interruption, and income assistance. LA voters get it. It’s why they overwhelmingly backed Measure J.

There are plenty of successful models to build upon:

CAHOOTS in Eugene, Oregon, provides mental health, homelessness, and addiction assistance, diverts 17% of police call volume. It saves the city ~$8.5 million annually, while significantly reducing fatal encounters with law enforcement.
Denver’s Supportive Housing Social Impact Bond Initiative showed that unhoused people who were referred to supportive housing experienced a 34% reduction in police contacts and a 40% reduction in arrests — at dramatically lower public costs.

The success of these models is supported by a wide and growing body of research:

Basic income experiments are also consistently showing promise in reducing violence and promoting public safety:

A Basic Annual Income experiment in Manitoba, Canada was found to have a strong negative effect on both violence and property crime compared to nearby towns with similar populations and demographics.

But all of this gets pushed aside as people start arguing for big increases in police spending. (And the push will just get more intense over the next few years, as the 2028 Olympics are used as further pretext for spending more on police, and inevitably less on prevention.) These false narratives are about stopping change, frightening the public, and upending our politics by scaring elected officials into skewing right.

I won’t do that. I’m going to keep fighting for the long-overdue change we need.

That’s the only way we will keep everyone safe.

--

--

--

Councilmember representing the Westside of LA; Director, LA Metro; Comic book fan; Dad and Husband.

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

Kurt Bardella is afraid of me

Minnesota: The Most Important Swing State

I Met Bernie Sanders for my Make A Wish and Now I am Voting Joe Biden

Christianity Has A Different Meaning to Me

Did Ukraine REALLY Request Russian ‘Help’?

Trump

A social care election in review

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Mike Bonin

Mike Bonin

Councilmember representing the Westside of LA; Director, LA Metro; Comic book fan; Dad and Husband.

More from Medium

SILONG Songs Issue 1: Eraserheads’ ‘Toyang’

‘Father Brown’: S09.E08. “The Wayward Girls”

Don’t Wake Virginia

Why is the Bible the Authority